The video shows a police dog severely abusing the Uber driver who lost his car payment San Francisco
Recently released video footage shows California police officers using a police dog to seriously injure an Uber driver, who was late in paying for the car he rented to do his job. .
San Ramon police arrested Ali Badr, a 42-year-old Egyptian immigrant, in December 2020 after a rental company reported that his vehicle was stolen. In images obtained by the San Francisco Chronicle, you can see the city police in the Bay Area release the dog on the barefoot driver and without warning without warning within seconds after stopping him, although Badr did not resist.
The dog grabbed Badr’s right arm for almost a minute, abusing him so severely that it required multiple surgeries. In a lawsuit filed last month, Badr, who was never charged, said he was left with “serious physical and psychological injuries” and has not regained full use of his arm and hand since the incident.
“They’re all talking to me at once,” Badr told the Chronicle. “They’re calling me, and they all have guns out. I did exactly what they say.”
The case has shed some light not only on the tactics of the police department, but also on the rental agreements used by shared travel companies such as Uber and Lyft.
Badr, who was a social worker in Egypt before moving to the U.S., previously drove for Uber and Lyft in his own vehicle, but could no longer pay the payments after the pandemic reduced his income, the newspaper reported. In August 2020, according to the lawsuit, he acquired a car owned by car-sharing startup CarMommy through a rental agreement with HyreCar, a car rental company that serves concert workers.
He was late in his payments towards the end of the contract, the Chronicle reported, but made arrangements to pay the company. CarMommy CEO John Blomeke complained that the vehicle was stolen, which in the contract Badr signed could happen if he was late in payments and “other criteria were met,” according to the newspaper. HyreCar declined to comment on the matter, while Uber and CarMommy did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Rental agreements like these became commonplace as Uber and Lyft expanded across the United States. Short-term car rentals through partners like HyreCar offer fewer jumping hoops than regular car rental deals, and short-term car rentals gave Uber and Lyft access to a new group of drivers.
But some drivers have argued that rental agreements can be predatory, sometimes requiring higher rent and other costs in exchange for a lower salary. For some drivers like Badr, it was sometimes difficult to do enough to cover the monthly or weekly payments, at which point drivers usually had to return the vehicle immediately. For many, this meant losing at least one source of income and, in some cases, their temporary housing.
The video from the board and body camera shows Badr, who appears to be trying to put on his shoes, cooperating with the demands of the officers during a traffic stop. But in a matter of seconds, an officer releases the big dog who immediately bites Badr’s arm. As the dog attacks him, Badr shouts and shouts repeatedly, “What have I done? What did I do?” while officers inspect the car with their weapons unsheathed.
Badr told the Chronicle that after being transported by ambulance, he was handcuffed to a hospital bed and operated on for his injuries. Police in riot gear stormed a rally on Friday, removing hundreds of protesters by truck. Police in riot gear stormed a rally on Friday, removing hundreds of protesters by truck. said a DA spokesman.
The San Ramon Police Department did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
According to his lawsuit, Badr suffered “permanent and extensive” damage to his arm and hand, which was very marked, and has “undergone substantial mental health treatment and therapy.” The city of San Ramon, the police chief and officers are called to the lawsuit, along with HyreCar, CarMommy and the company’s CEO, Blomeke.
U.S. police dogs bite thousands of people each year and are often used on people who are not violent or suspected of petty crime or, in some cases, no crime, a Marshall Project investigation found. Victims of these attacks are struggling to claim responsibility, as lawsuits for excessive force involving dog bites are difficult to win, according to the media.